Skip to main content
Small business owner meeting with an advisor to review health insurance options

Do I Need a Broker for Small Business Health Insurance?

You can buy small business coverage with or without one. Here is what a broker does, how they are paid, and how to decide what fits your business.

What a Broker Does for a Small Business

A broker is a licensed insurance professional who helps you find, set up, and keep health coverage for your team. Here is what that looks like in practice.

Compares your options

A broker can look across more than one insurance company for you, so you are not reading each company's offer on your own and trying to line them up.

Handles the setup

From the application to enrollment paperwork to getting your employees signed up, an advisor can take the process off your plate so you can keep running your business.

Stays available after you sign

Questions about a new hire, a claim, or next year's plan do not stop once coverage starts. A broker is someone you can call when they come up.

You can buy coverage without a broker, and some owners do. It mostly comes down to how much of the shopping, paperwork, and follow-up you would rather hand off.

Compliance guidance icon

The Rules Depend on the Size of Your Business

Employers with 50 or more full-time employees, including full-time equivalents, face additional ACA requirements, and Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware each have their own continuation rules for small employers. A broker keeps track of which ones apply to your team, so you are not searching for them yourself.

A Quick Way to Decide

There is no single right answer for every business. See which side sounds more like yours.

Handshake icon

A broker may help most if

Benefits land on you or an office manager, and there is no HR person to hand them to.
You are buying group coverage for the first time, or moving from one type of coverage to another.
Your team is growing, or you have employees who live in different states.
You want someone to call when an employee has a question or a claim goes wrong.
You are weighing a group plan against options like an ICHRA and want help comparing them.
Computer screen icon

You may be fine on your own if

You are comfortable comparing plans and reading the fine print yourself.
Someone on your staff already handles benefits and keeps up with the rules.
You already know which plan you want and do not expect to change it.
You have the time to handle enrollment, questions, and renewals as they come up.

If you land somewhere in the middle, that is common. A short conversation with an advisor can help you sort out what you would rather hand off and what you are happy to keep.

Common Questions About Using a Broker

What does a benefits broker do?

A benefits broker is a licensed professional who helps a business find, set up, and keep health coverage for its team. That can include comparing options from different insurance companies, helping with the application and employee enrollment, and being available afterward for questions about claims, new hires, and renewals.

Can I buy small business health insurance without a broker?

Yes. Using a broker is a choice, not a requirement. Employers can shop for coverage on their own, including through options like the SHOP marketplace, and many do. The trade-off is that you take on the comparing, the paperwork, and the follow-up yourself.

Is a broker different from an agent?

The two terms overlap, and both are licensed to sell insurance. In general, an agent may work for a single insurance company, while a broker may represent several. If you are considering a professional, ask which companies they work with so you know how wide a comparison to expect.

How do I know if a broker is licensed?

Ask for their license number and the states where they are licensed, then confirm it with that state's insurance department. Our advisors are licensed to advise clients in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware.

I already have a plan. Can a broker still help?

Yes. Many owners bring in an advisor at renewal, when their team grows, or when something about their coverage stops working. An advisor can review your current plan alongside other options and help you decide whether a change makes sense.

Does a broker work with more than one insurance company?

Often, yes. A broker may represent several insurance companies, which lets them compare options for you in one conversation. Ask any broker you are considering which companies they work with, since that decides how many options you will see.

This FAQ is general information about how brokers work, not legal or insurance advice. Every situation is different, so talk with a licensed advisor about yours.

Meet Our Small Group and ICHRA Advisors

Want Help Deciding?

Tell us about your team and what you have today, and we will talk through whether working with an advisor makes sense for you. No pressure, just a clear answer.

Disclosures

We are compensated by the insurance carriers for policies you choose through us. There is no direct cost to you. Compensation may vary by carrier and product. Information on this page is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal, tax, or accounting advice. Please consult your professional advisors about your specific situation. We are licensed to advise clients in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware. Contact us to confirm availability in other states.